Suspend Judgment! Notes from The India Way at the Drucker Forum

Lessons from the India Way 2026 session in Vienna: Tata, JLR, Titan and the case for companies built to last, and why suspending judgment comes first.

Vidyotham Reddi

11/4/20265 min read

On Tuesday, the day before the 18th Global Peter Drucker Forum opened in Vienna, I sat at a breakout table in the Maria Theresien Apartments of the Hofburg. The session was "The India Way 2026: Protecting Golden Goose Enterprises", and I was there as Chief Analytics Officer of RSB Insights, at the invitation of Unni Krishnan of the LivingMachine Institute.

The question put to our table was simple to ask and hard to answer: what one act of rejuvenation should a company undertake to build long-term value?

My answer was two words: suspend judgment.

To my surprise, Unni picked it up in his closing remarks. Here is why I said it, and what the speakers taught me about it over the afternoon.

The great invisible wall

Unni did not mince words. Every company, he said, has a "great invisible wall": the unspoken, unwritten and unheard voices that add up to the firm's "collective cognitive garbage". Does it ring a bell? It should. It exists in every company, here and now.

His point was that you cannot suspend judgment until you face that wall. The wall is the knife edge between creative destruction, where you destroy your own dogmas, and self-destruction, where you stay wedded to them. Stay wedded long enough, and you are bleeding value that no financial statement reports.

As an economist, I would put it this way: a dogma is a 'prior' you never update. Suspending judgment is simply the discipline of updating it.

Unni also made a point that every analytics leader should sit with for a moment. A great deal of a company's perpetuity value, the value of being around for a very long time, never shows up in its financial statements. If we cannot see it, we do not manage it. And if we do not manage it, we throw it away.

Owner, or custodian?

Harish Bhat Ji, author of Doing the Right Thing: Learnings from Ratan Tata, delivered the Ratan Tata Memorial Lecture. The story I keep coming back to is a small one. When a colleague told Ratan Tata he needed to safeguard his legacy, he replied: "It's not my legacy." He saw himself as the custodian of a Tata legacy going back to Jamsetji Tata in 1868.

That is a very different job description. An owner of a legacy defends it. A custodian keeps asking whether it is still being lived.

Harish Ji gave examples of what that meant in practice: walking away from profitable opportunities that could not be pursued with integrity; making sure no depositor lost money in the Tata Finance crisis, beyond what the law required; and, after the 2008 Mumbai attacks, setting up a welfare trust not just for Taj employees and guests but for families across the city.

Strengths first: the JLR decision

Ravi Kant Ji, former Vice Chairman of Tata Motors and author of Leading from the Back, told the story of Jaguar Land Rover. In 2008, Tata Motors was mostly a maker of trucks and buses. Plenty of people asked whether it had any business bidding for two British icons.

What struck me, as someone who has spent 25+ years building decision models, was how the team made the call. Most due diligence starts with what is wrong. Ravi Kant Ji's team started with what was right, and they found five strengths, none of them financial:

  1. Quality had improved a lot, after heavy factory investment by Ford and, earlier, BMW.

  2. A new product line had been fully tested.

  3. A strong engineering and design organization.

  4. Dealers who kept their passion for the brand through years of losses.

  5. A brand that was tarnished but could be renewed.

Add the two things Tata brought (cost discipline and a sharper focus on customers in each market), and the decision became, in his words, simple. Tata paid ~$2.3 billion in 2008. In fiscal 2012–13, its fifth year under Tata, JLR made ~$2.6 billion (£1.68 billion) before tax, more than the price Tata paid for the whole company.

Think about that for a second. The data that mattered most was not on the balance sheet. It was in the factories, the engineering team and the dealerships, and you only find it if you suspend judgment long enough to look.

Ravi Kant Ji's framework for "leading from the back" starts in the same place: have an open mind, take ownership and be detached. "The more successful you are," he said, "the more close-minded you become." He defined trust as "consistent integrity", including intellectual honesty, which he weighs even above financial honesty because "by the time you catch it, it may be too late".

Titan: the contrarian bet

Ravi Kant Ji and Harish Bhat Ji then told the Titan story. When almost the entire Indian watch market was mechanical, Titan's founding MD, Xerxes Desai, bet on quartz, because the consumer was changing even if the market was not. Titan recruited its first factory team from needy families in Tamil Nadu, trained them from scratch and, Harish said, watched many of them go on to graduate degrees. Its programme was literally called "People First".

The long view, and a hard conversation

Mark Goyder, founder of Tomorrow's Company, reminded us that fiduciary duty originally meant a duty to the thing you own, especially a living thing. He cited research by Haruo Funabashi on Japan's long-lived companies, by his count more than 20,000 over 100 years old, and the patterns they share: clear values, a strong sense of legacy, people, society, innovation and financial prudence. He also cited Eric Ries's Incorruptible and its meta-analysis finding that employee-owned firms consistently outperform. His closing line, borrowed from a German at an Aspen seminar, will stay with me: "You all want the harvest at Easter."

Finally, Cheryl Rodness, Chief Brand Officer of Quest Global, showed what "force for good" means inside a company. Quest's research with YouGov in India found that an estimated 70 million working women are at risk of leaving the workforce after unsupported pregnancy loss, and 78 million fear losing their jobs if they disclose it. Quest's answer, Break the Silence, trains managers, runs a 24/7 helpline and safe circles, and is now open to other companies to join. It was, quite literally, a company facing its own invisible wall.

So, why suspend judgment?

Because every one of these stories started there. The JLR deal started with looking for strengths instead of weaknesses. Titan started with seeing a consumer the market had not yet noticed. Break the Silence started with listening to employees about a topic nobody talked about.

Here is my strong POV: the real contrast is 'verdict first' vs. 'evidence first'. Companies that last are not the ones that are never wrong. They are the ones that keep checking.

Is it easy? No, it is not! Is it necessary? Absolutely!!

So here is my question for you: which judgment about your business have you not tested in the last five years?

Unni and his team are now working on "The Vienna Declaration" from this session. I look forward to seeing it, and to two more days of the Forum.

Vidyotham Reddi is Chief Analytics Officer of RSB Insights & Analytics. Reach him at vidyotham@rsbinsights.com.

Get the newsletter